This blog is supposed to document my efforts to teach myself to cook “Chinese.” My parents didn’t cook, but my sister and I had a Shanghainese ayi, so she cooked for us. I still remember how my ayi would pull her own noodles and make scallion pancakes by hand. I have tried recreating these feats, but with little success.
What’s really driving this blog, though, is my continued confusion about identity. I was born in the U.S. but my parents are Chinese, so I’ve often wondered what exactly that makes me. In fact, I wonder if my parents are even technically Chinese, because they both were raised in Taiwan and then became U.S. citizens. It’s a whole big mess. The New York Times says I’m not alone, and that race is an ever-shifting concept. The message I’m supposed take from articles such as these, I suppose, is that I should stop worrying.
Now and again, however, I worry. This spring, Stuff White People Like became a huge success in the blogosphere. My friends and I had a good old laugh reading the list the first time we saw it. But then I noticed I shared many of the tastes mentioned on the site. Farmers’ markets, the Sunday New York Times, scarves. The list represents my tastes so accurately that my boyfriend, who is white, says I am whiter than he is. This disturbs me.
It disturbs me because I wonder if I’ve been complicit in the cultivation of my tastes. My parents moved to leafy, suburban New Jersey so my sister and I would have access to the best public schools. Somewhere around middle school one of my friends invited me to sing with her in her church choir, and I went along. Never did she ask me to attend worship or even Sunday school with her; I just went by myself. And I loved it. In fact I ended up much more involved with that community of faith than she. I remain deeply attached to the church and I consider its many members the village that raised me.
That village had a deep impact on my preferences, however. Imagine an upper-middle class WASP: private school, private music lessons, advanced degrees. Now change your image into someone of Chinese descent, and that’s me. I never aimed to be white, but I so wanted to fit in, and now I have more in common with a list of stuff white people like than a list of stuff Asian people like. And there does, in fact, exist such a list. Rather than laughing when I read it, I felt instead felt a profound sense of loss. I was supposed belong this list, not the white list. What happened to me?